Moving to Canada from the US: a fresh start, with strings attached
Moving to Canada brings some genuine tax advantages for newcomers, along with a few traps, especially for US citizens, who never stop filing in the US.
A step-up in cost on arrival
When you become a Canadian resident, you are generally treated as having acquired most of your property at its fair market value on the day you arrive. Gains that built up before you moved are therefore not taxed by Canada when you later sell. Keep evidence of those arrival-date values; you will need it years from now.
The US does not give the same step-up. If you remain a US taxpayer, a later sale can produce a much larger US gain than Canadian gain, so timing and foreign tax credits matter.
Your first Canadian return
In your year of arrival you report worldwide income only from the date you became resident. Your federal and provincial credits are generally prorated for the part of the year you lived in Canada.
Foreign property reporting
Starting in the year after you arrive, if the total cost of your foreign property, including US bank and brokerage accounts, is more than CA$100,000 at any time in the year, you must file Form T1135 with your return. Penalties for missing it can be steep even when no tax is owing.
US retirement accounts
401(k)s and traditional IRAs can generally continue to grow without current Canadian tax under the treaty. Roth IRAs need more care: you can keep their tax-free treatment in Canada by making a one-time treaty election and not contributing after you arrive.
US citizens keep filing
The US taxes its citizens wherever they live. As a US citizen in Canada you will still file a US return every year, plus the FBAR and possibly Form 8938. Foreign tax credits usually eliminate most US tax on Canadian income, but planning is needed to keep it that way, particularly with Canadian TFSAs, Canadian mutual funds and the sale of a home.
Before you cross the border
- Document the fair market value of your investments and property on your arrival date.
- Review Roth IRA contributions and any US accounts your Canadian broker cannot hold.
- If you are a US citizen, think twice before opening a TFSA or buying Canadian mutual funds.
Moving north?
We plan both sides of your move so nothing falls through the cracks. About our entry tax planning service
This article is general information, not tax advice. Rules change and every situation is different, so speak with a qualified advisor before acting.
